Sefarim by Rabbi Chaim Cohen: Mekor Chaim ↗ בס״ד

A Photograph with a Sefer Torah

Question: Before our son’s bar mitzva, the photographer suggested taking the sefer Torah out of the aron kodesh so that he could be photographed holding it. Is this permissible?

Answer: The Shulchan Aruch (OC 135:14), based on the Yerushalmi (Yoma 7:1), rules that a Sefer Torah should not be brought to prisoners, even on Rosh Hashana and Yom Kippur, so that they can hear kerias HaTorah. The Rema permits this if it is brought a day or two beforehand, or for an adam chashuv. The Mishna Berura (135:47) explains that a Sefer Torah’s honour is that people should go to it.

The poskim discuss a similar issue regarding shnayim mikra. The Baer Heitev (OC 285:1), citing the Radbaz (3:564) and the Arizal, writes that someone proficient in the trop and vowels should read the parsha from a Sefer Torah. The Mishna Berura (285:2) considers this a hiddur. However, R’ Yehuda Altman (Mei Yehuda OC 40 quoted in Yalkut Yosef 143:5, n7) cautions against unnecessary use of a Sefer Torah, explaining that the practices of the Arizal and Vilna Gaon are not necessarily a precedent for others.

The Shach (YD 270:5), citing the Perisha, similarly writes that, since we can learn from printed sefarim, there is no reason to use a Sefer Torah unnecessarily. R’ Yissachar Shlomo Teichtal (Mishne Sachir OC 92) applies this to someone wishing to practise leining from a Sefer Torah. Since this can be done using a printed tikkun, he rules that there is no justification for taking it out, unless it is a new Sefer Torah which also needs checking.

R’ Moshe Sternbuch (Teshuvos Vehanhagos 4:73) distinguishes between private and communal Sifrei Torah. He maintains that the hiddur of reading shnayim mikra applies to a privately owned Sefer Torah, whereas a communal one is designated for public reading. R’ Yitzchak Yaakov Weiss (Minchas Yitzchak 9:19) similarly notes that this is not the accepted practice today and may constitute unnecessary handling of a Sefer Torah.

R’ Yitzchak Yosef (ibid.) permits taking out a Sefer Torah specially to read Parshas Zachor for women, since this fulfils a genuine need (l’tzorech), and therefore the concern raised by the Shach does not apply. A photograph, however, does not constitute such a need.

In conclusion, although such a photograph may be meaningful, it does not justify taking a communal Sefer Torah out of the Aron Kodesh without a genuine halachic need.

Comments