Black Stripes on the Tallis
Question: I am buying my first tallis . The shopkeeper told me that as an Ashkenazi, I should choose one with black stripes. What is the reason for this? Answer: Rambam (Tzitzis 2:8) and Rashi (Menachos 41b) write that the tzitzis should be the same colour as the tallis . For example, if the tallis were red, the tzitzis would also be red. The Shulchan Aruch Harav (OC 9:9) explains, based on the Torah’s wording, that the tzitzis should match the corner of the garment in both colour and material. This implies that not only the material but also the colour of the tzitzis should be similar to that of the tallis . Tosafos (Menachos 41b), however, disagrees. They explain that there is certainly no Torah requirement for this practice, although it may be connected to the idea of ‘zeh eli ve’anveihu’ beautifying the mitzva . Similarly, the Rashba (3:280) holds that there is no such obligation. The Shulchan Aruch Harav and Magen Avraham (9:6), quoting the Bach (OC 9:3), writes that th...