Question: Last Rosh Hashana I went to a
different shul to normal. I started saying the yehi ratzon
printed in my machzor between the tekios but someone motioned for
me not to say it. Can I say it if I want to?
Answer: The Shulchan Aruch (OC 592:3) writes
that one should not talk between the various tekios. The Tur (OC 592:2)
writes that while one who spoke would not need to repeat the berachos
and listen to the shofar again, nonetheless, they should be told not to
talk. The Rema adds that davening and shofar related speech does
not constitute a hefsek, unnecessary interruption.
R’ Benzion Abba Shaul (Ohr Letzion 1:39) maintains that
there is no hefsek to recite the yehi ratzon, being that
according to the Arizal, such words of vidui are appropriate during the
blowing of the shofar. Similarly, the Mateh Ephraim (590:36) records the
minhag to recite the yehi ratzon, though cautions against
reciting the names of the malachim, angels.
Nonetheless, the Mishna Berura (592:12) writes that the Rema
is specifically referring to the tefillos in between each set of blasts.
One must not make such interruptions in the middle of a set, however.
Therefore, one should not recite the yehi ratzon that is printed in the machzor.
He notes (Shaar Hatziyun 592:15) that R’ Yaakov Emden (Siddur Beis Yaakov) was
lenient in this regard. If one is in a place where the minhag is to
recite yehi ratzon, one should not stop them.
R’ Ovadia Yosef (Yabia Omer OC 1:36:18; OC 3:32) quotes the
Minchas Elazar (1:75) who challenges the minhag to recite them. The Beis
Yosef (OC 590) writes that there is a machlokes as to why we must blow a
minimum of thirty blasts. According to Rambam (Shofar 3:2), the reason is because there is a safek
(doubt) as to which is the correct sound for teruah. Accordingly, we
blow three sets to ensure that we fulfil the mitzva. Therefore, R’
Ovadia argues, it would be a hefsek to interrupt with any tefillos
in the middle. Additionally, there are some unsavoury names that have made
their way into the text which must not be uttered (See Minchas Elazar
1:75).
R’ Shmuel Wosner (Shevet Halevi 5:65:3) and R’ Moshe
Sternbuch (Teshuvos Vehanhagos 1:344) note that many great Rabbis never said this
yehi ratzon.
In conclusion, unless one has a specific minhag to
say the yehi ratzon, it is best not to recite it.
Thursday, 17 September 2020
Yehi Ratzon During Shofar
Sunday, 13 September 2020
Blowing Shofar for Another
Question: I have been asked to blow shofar for people who are housebound.
Should I repeat the berachos each time even though I have already
fulfilled the mitzva?
Answer: The Gemara (Rosh Hashana 29a with Rashi; Shavuos 39a) teaches that
Jewish people are spiritually responsible for each other. As such, one person
can recite certain berachos for another even if they don’t need to
recite it themselves. The Magen Avraham (167:40) explains that because of this
responsibility (arvus), if one knows that another person hasn’t
performed a mitzva, it is almost as if they haven’t performed the mitzva
themselves. Therefore, one who has already fulfilled their obligation for kiddush
can recite kiddush for another person who has not.
There is a machlokes as to
whether one can recite a beracha on a mitzva that one is not
commanded to perform. The Shulchan Aruch (OC 589:6) writes that as women are
not obligated to hear the shofar, they do not recite the beracha as
they cannot say vetzivanu, that ‘we are commanded’. Accordingly, a man
blowing for women could not recite the beracha on their behalf.
R’ Ovadia Yosef (Yabia Omer OC 1:39-42;
4:50; 5:43) writes that this is the practice for sefardim, and women should
not recite the beracha of shehecheyanu either. However, ashkenazim follow the
Rema who writes that women can recite the beracha as the Jewish people
were commanded collectively. Other sefardim follow the Ben Ish Chai (Rav
Poalim OC 1 Sod Yesharim 12) and Kaf Hachaim (OC 589:23) who write that women
may recite the berachos.
Nonetheless, the Rema writes that a man
may not recite the beracha if blowing shofar for women if he has
already heard shofar. The Rema (Darkei Moshe OC 589:2) quotes the
Maharil who writes that a man may recite the beracha for a woman who cannot do so. Yet, the Rema
disagrees, writing that while women may say the beracha if they want to,
it remains optional, and so a man shouldn’t do so on their behalf.
The Mishna Berura (585:5) writes that even
when blowing for other men, it is ideal for the ones listening to recite the berachos,
rather than the one blowing shofar
to repeat them.
In conclusion, one blowing shofar after
they have already fulfilled the mitzva should ask one of those listening to
recite the berachos. He may recite the berachos on behalf of
other men if necessary.